Mudcat Café message #1658932 The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #88448   Message #1658932
Posted By: Paul Burke
01-Feb-06 - 08:07 AM
Thread Name: BS: FLAME and radical liberal anti-semitism
Subject: RE: BS: FLAME and radical liberal anti-semitism
So you're saying Israel isn't a Jewish state? Or that Germany shouldn't be pluralist? I didn't say anything about state boundaries; they are necessary constructs for administrative convenience. And as for "Any people living together in a coherent patch of land should have the right to decide to live in a country of their own", don't talk tripe. As Woodrow Wison is supposed to have said sadly, "I didn't realise there were so many small nations".

No one has a "right" to live in a country "of their own". They have the right to live wherever they live. And they have the right not to be evicted to make space for someone else's project.

I'm assuming your rather odd formulation (living together/ coherent patch of land) wasn't a deliberate attempt to leave out the Roma.