I would have thought that Dougie Maclean's Caledonia would have been in that poll, as many people came to know it through the Frankie Miller version which was used as a well- known Scottish beer advert, and had more of a "pop" sound to it, contrasting with Dougie's definitely folk original.as Allan C has suggested, it is often requested in a pub session by people who are probably not "folkies" but just happen to have ventured into that pub that day/evening.